CIRCLES, credited with Don Toliver, is track 13 of the 18-track BULLY released on March 28, 2026, where MusicBrainz credits Ye as its artist and producer.
Catalog context only, from MusicBrainz; no reviewed critical source describes this song yet.
Sources & recording details
Explanation & sources
An original summary of documented musical or release context. Reviewed 11/8/2026.
- BULLY (digital release 5fe938fb)
MusicBrainz · Track 13
Track position, artist credit and producer relationship.
Other producers credited by MusicBrainz: 88‐Keys, Don Toliver.
Listen
Song links to the listed streaming catalogs. A particular mix, master or archive edition is not verified. Availability may vary by country and account.
Listening link checks
- Spotify: CIRCLES · Kanye West, Ye · BULLY. Catalog source (opens in a new tab). Song and album identity checked; playback not tested.
- Apple Music: CIRCLES · Kanye West · BULLY. Catalog source (opens in a new tab). Song and album identity checked; playback not tested.
Recordings
These are indexed catalog entries. Distinct metadata does not establish an audible revision or audio equivalence. Audio is not hosted.
BULLY (digital release)
Catalog duration: 1:31
Position 13 of 18 in BULLY (digital release)
Recording sources & evidence
Catalog title: CIRCLES (Ye feat. Don Toliver; MusicBrainz 5fe938fb)
MusicBrainz recording 676e48b2-e57f-4e6d-b98c-63f72b4a2c5c. A matching title does not establish identity with the other BULLY release's recording.
Sources & evidence
View field-level evidence (4 claims)
Song identity · field
trackIdArchive summary: Track 13 is a recording of CIRCLES.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY (digital release 5fe938fb) →Kind
Archive summary: Album recording on an official release.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY (digital release 5fe938fb) →Duration · field
durationSecondsArchive summary: Displayed length 1:31.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY (digital release 5fe938fb) →Release membership · field
releaseIdsArchive summary: Listed at track 13.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY (digital release 5fe938fb) →
Archive detail
Record ID: rv-bully-circles-5fe938fb
Evidence is assessed claim by claim. An association or a source confidence label does not establish a recording credit.
About the archive & methodBULLY - DELUXE (digital release)
Catalog duration: 1:31
Position 13 of 20 in BULLY - DELUXE (digital release)
Recording sources & evidence
Catalog title: CIRCLES (Ye; MusicBrainz e398f34d)
MusicBrainz recording 2e73302f-222d-4623-ab32-4d98b7aa4663. A matching title does not establish identity with the other BULLY release's recording.
Sources & evidence
View field-level evidence (4 claims)
Song identity · field
trackIdArchive summary: Track 13 is a recording of CIRCLES.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY deluxe (digital release e398f34d) →Kind
Archive summary: Album recording on an official release.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY deluxe (digital release e398f34d) →Duration · field
durationSecondsArchive summary: Displayed length 1:31.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY deluxe (digital release e398f34d) →Release membership · field
releaseIdsArchive summary: Listed at track 13.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY deluxe (digital release e398f34d) →
Archive detail
Record ID: rv-bully-circles-e398f34d
Evidence is assessed claim by claim. An association or a source confidence label does not establish a recording credit.
About the archive & method
Credits
- Recording-specific Ye role
- artist, producer (documented)
Evidence applies to the cited recording only, not every track or the whole catalog.
Related people
Imported associations may describe a feature or another contribution. Exact roles and recordings have not been independently reverified.
Date & editorial context
- Date context
- 3/28/2026 (edition unverified) · linked release
Inherited from the linked release, not independently verified as this track's first release date. Imported catalog-date claim with a linked reference. The exact territory, edition and date have not been independently reverified for this release record.
- Editorial era
- BULLY · 2024–
Editorial grouping, not a sourced historical boundary.
Sources & evidence
View field-level evidence (6 claims)
Title
Archive summary: Track 13 is titled CIRCLES.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY (digital release 5fe938fb) →Release status · field
statusArchive summary: The track appears on an official release.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY (digital release 5fe938fb) →Release membership · field
releaseIdsArchive summary: The track is on this album.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY (digital release 5fe938fb) →Catalog artist attribution · field
primaryArtistIdsArchive summary: The track artist credit begins with Ye: Ye feat. Don Toliver.
Imported catalog artist attribution. The artist identity, display name and recording credit have not been independently reverified.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY (digital release 5fe938fb) →Ye role on this recording · field
yeRolesArchive summary: Ye is the credited track artist and has a producer relationship to the recording.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY (digital release 5fe938fb) →Person association · field
featureArtistIdsArchive summary: The track artist credit reads Ye feat. Don Toliver.
Imported person association. It may describe a feature or another contribution. The exact role and recording have not been independently reverified.
Source location: Track 13: CIRCLES
MusicBrainz: BULLY (digital release 5fe938fb) →
Archive detail
Record ID: trk-bully-circles
Evidence is assessed claim by claim. An association or a source confidence label does not establish a recording credit.
About the archive & method